Covered Calls: The Classic Strategy for Consistent Income

Photo of author

By Barron Schwartz

A covered call is a traditional, highly sought-after options trading strategy that enables shareholders to earn extra cash on existing shares and gain some downside protection through premium capture, making it a best Options Income Strategy for conservative or income-oriented traders in neutral to moderately bullish markets. The presupposition is to have at least 100 shares of stock and simultaneously sell an option on them with the obligation to sell them to the buyer at a mutually agreed strike price if the option is exercised before or at expiration. This strategy allows investors to make money in consolidation of the underlying stock price through earning premiums while being able to participate in limited upside movement to the strike price. For instance, the investor holds 100 shares of XYZ Company at $50 and sells a call option with a 1-month $55 strike price for $2 per share, or $200, and XYZ remains below $55 at expiration, the option expires worthless, the investor retains their 100 shares, and the $200 premium is profit. When the stock goes over $55, the option is exercised and the stock is sold for $55, making $500 profit on the stock and a $200 premium for a total gain of $700. The investor sacrifices any further profit beyond $55, which is the disadvantage of the strategy. This expense—taking potential profits hostage for immediate income—is the very nature of the covered call and why it is most suitable for flat or steady appreciation markets, not blowout rallies. Investors may utilize several strike price options depending on their expectation: out-of-the-money calls (strike prices above the present price) combine income and upside, in-the-money calls (strike prices below the present price) are more costly protection and premium but less upside. Downside risk is not eliminated, but the premium collected lowers the effective breakeven, providing the investor with a buffer. Covered calls also complement dividend stocks because the call premiums and dividend payments form a double source of income that ends up raising yield. The strategy is therefore particularly valuable to conservative or retiree investors who would like to maximize return on a buy-and-hold portfolio. In addition, the strategy is tax-efficient in certain locations in the sense that premiums can be considered short-term capital gains, and at the time of expenditure in IRAs or other tax-deferred programs, the investor escapes tax consequences altogether. Covered calls are highly adaptable and can be modified in-flight by rolling—closing a previous call and opening a new call with a different strike or expiration—to capitalize on a change in the market or to keep generating income if the underlying is neutral. Investors also use technical analysis in determining their strike choice, taking a call strike at levels of resistance so that they do not end up with the option most likely to be worthless at expiration. This saves the premium and the underlying stock. Covered calls are utilized with protective puts (collar creation), or with the wheel strategy, selling puts to buy stock and then selling calls on exercised shares. The “rinse-and-repeat” arrangement earns on getting into and out of a trade and can be done every month. Also notable is that covered calls may be employed not only on individual stocks but even on ETFs like SPY, QQQ, or sector funds for diversified market and diversified income strategy. Assignment risk must be brought to investors’ attention, especially on ex-dividend dates or if the option just so happens to be deep in-the-money, since early assignment might take place and impinge on dividend capture. Covered calls should be managed with an eye towards earnings dates, macroeconomic events, and market forces that make the underlying stock volatile or alter its price. Volatile stocks are fine to sell premium on but can get called away or lose on the underlying, while low-implied-volatility stocks might not be able to generate enough premium to make the trade worthwhile. Therefore, the underlying quality is paramount: the optimal underlying should exhibit solid fundamentals, a rising or stable, steadily priced firm, and ample option liquidity to accommodate variable strike and expiry options. On its part as a returns machine, provided used normally in moderation, covered calls can also perform exceedingly well against dormant shareholding in flat markets by benefiting from time decay (theta) and dampening volatility. They also cause expectations to anchor so that the traders will begin thinking in terms of probabilities and actual outcomes instead of endless returns. Provability of premium income leads to emotional self-discipline, lowering the tendency to act irrationally when the market encounters a hiccup. Most of our covered call investors also monitor spreadsheets or options-trading programs for such metrics as annualized return on premium (ROI), delta exposure, and probability of assignment so that they can make more knowledgeable numerical choices. During periods of low bond yields and inflation, covered calls are a desirable alternative to fixed income in traditional packages and come with higher yields and relatively little risk. They also regularly prove useful with hedge funds and institutional investors in structured income strategies. By and large, the approach is simple and generic, so it is readily feasible to apply it to other objectives—structured portfolio discipline, tactical hedging, or passive monthly cash. Though not recommended in extremely bullish markets since there is no upside potential, the covered call otherwise ranks as one of the most conservative, easy, and sure methods to earn portfolio income, risk removal, and discipline for investing in stocks, and, in the skilled hands of patient long-run investors, can turn an idle stock into a consistent yield payer.